New Dehli - In a groundbreaking move, the Bharatiya Nyaya (Second) Sanhita (BNS) has garnered Presidential assent, heralding the dawn of a new era by replacing the antiquated Indian Penal Code that has stood for 163 years. Despite this monumental change, the Central government is yet to announce the enforcement date.
Legislative Triumph in Rajya Sabha
The journey of transformation began in Rajya Sabha, where three pivotal bills, namely Bharatiya Nyaya (Second) Sanhita, Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha (Second) Sanhita (to replace the Code of Criminal Procedure), and Bharatiya Sakshya (Second) Sanhita (aiming to supplant the Indian Evidence Act), secured passage through a resounding voice vote. Union Home Minister Amit Shah championed the bills, paving the way for a seismic shift in the country's legal framework.
December 12 Redux
On December 12, the Centre reintroduced the revised criminal bills in the lower house of the Indian parliament, retracting the earlier versions unveiled in August. This strategic move underscored the government's commitment to a comprehensive legal overhaul.
Restructuring Offences and Introducing Community Service
A pivotal aspect of the BNS is the reordering of section numbers for offenses outlined in the Indian Penal Code. Notably, Section 4 introduces community service as a novel form of punishment, albeit without a defined scope. Offenses such as attempted suicide, defamation, public misconduct by an inebriated individual, and non-compliance with specified time and place regulations can now incur community service in addition to the prescribed penalties.
Empowering Women and Children
BNS introduces a dedicated Chapter V, titled "Of Offenses Against Woman and Child Of Sexual Offences," consolidating all crimes related to women and children under a single, comprehensive umbrella. This strategic restructuring streamlines legal processes and enhances protection for vulnerable segments of society.
Addressing Marital Rape with a Progressive Stance
In a significant departure from the past, BNS acknowledges marital rape with a minor wife as a punishable offense. Section 63 carves out an exception, clarifying that sexual acts by a man with his wife under eighteen years of age will constitute rape. This progressive stance contrasts with the previous Indian Penal Code, where the age threshold was set at fifteen years.
The Supreme Court's 2017 judgment in Independent Thought v. Union of India played a pivotal role in reinterpreting statutory age limits, aligning legal provisions with contemporary norms and safeguarding the rights of minor wives.
As India ushers in this legal metamorphosis, the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita stands as a testament to the nation's commitment to justice, equality, and the protection of its most vulnerable citizens.
Sweeping Reforms: BNS Redefines Sexual Offenses in India
Deceptive Means and False Promises Criminalized
In a groundbreaking move, the Bharatiya Nyaya (Second) Sanhita (BNS) introduces a new offense related to sexual intercourse under Section 69. Individuals engaging in sexual intercourse through deceitful means or by falsely promising marriage, with no intention of fulfilling that promise, will face severe consequences. This act, not classified as rape, carries a penalty of imprisonment for up to ten years and a fine.
Stringent Measures for Gangrape of Minors
Section 70 of the BNS addresses the harrowing crime of gangrape against victims under eighteen years of age. Individuals involved in such heinous acts, acting in concert or with a common intention, will be individually held accountable for the offense of rape. The punishment is severe, with imprisonment for life, equating to the remainder of the perpetrator's natural life, and a possible fine or even death.
Notably, this provision aligns with the previous Section 376DA IPC, which prescribed enhanced punishment for victims under sixteen years of age.
Legal Scrutiny on Trial Court Proceedings
Section 73 of the BNS brings attention to the publication of trial court proceedings related to sexual offenses. Any printing or publishing of matter without the prior permission of the court is now deemed an offense. Violators could face imprisonment for up to two years and fines. However, it's important to clarify that printing or publishing judgments from High Courts or the Supreme Court is not covered under this section.
Section 377: A Significant Deletion
In a pivotal move reflecting societal evolution, BNS aligns itself with the landmark Supreme Court ruling in Navtej Singh Johar. The infamous Section 377 IPC, criminalizing consensual carnal intercourse, has been entirely removed from the legal landscape. Forced intercourse with an adult male and bestiality, previously considered offenses, are no longer punishable under the BNS.
India's legal framework takes a monumental stride forward with these progressive amendments, affirming its commitment to safeguarding individuals from sexual offenses while ensuring the legal system adapts to contemporary values and understanding.
Legal Landscape Transformed: BNS Revamps Offenses and Punishments
Adultery Omitted: A Shift in Legal Paradigm
In the wake of the Apex Court's landmark judgment in Joseph Shine's case, the second Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) boldly omits the offense of Adultery. However, Section 498 of the Indian Penal Code (Section 84) remains intact, penalizing a man for enticing another man's wife, facilitating intercourse with any person.
Embracing Organized Crime: Section 111
A significant addition to the legal arsenal, Section 111 of the BNS introduces provisions for organized crime. Defined comprehensively, it encompasses a spectrum of unlawful activities, from kidnapping and extortion to cyber-crimes and human trafficking. If such criminal actions result in a person's death, the prescribed punishment is the death penalty.
Punishment for Organized Crime Resulting in Death
- Death penalty or life imprisonment.
- Fine not less than ten lakh rupees.
Punishment for Organized Crime (Non-fatal)
- Imprisonment for a term not less than five years, extendable to life.
- Fine not less than five lakh rupees.
Membership in Organized Crime Syndicate: Strict Consequences
BNS stipulates severe penalties for individuals involved in organized crime syndicates. Membership in such syndicates invites imprisonment for a term not less than five years, possibly extending to life imprisonment. Additionally, fines of not less than five lakh rupees can be imposed.
Petty Organized Crime: Section 112
Addressing crimes at a grassroots level, Section 112 introduces provisions for Petty Organized Crime. Individuals engaged in acts such as theft, snatching, unauthorized selling of tickets, betting, or selling public examination question papers fall under this category.
Punishment for Petty Organized Crime
- Imprisonment for a term not less than one year, extendable to seven years.
- Fine as deemed appropriate by the court.
As the second BNS unfolds, these comprehensive amendments reflect a concerted effort to address evolving societal norms, aligning the legal framework with contemporary challenges while emphasizing stringent consequences for those engaging in organized and petty criminal activities.
Unveiling the New Legal Horizon: BNS Amendments Bring Pivotal Changes
Terrorist Act: A Comprehensive Redefinition
In a monumental stride towards national security, the criminal law amendment introduces the "Terrorist Act" to the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), surpassing its absence in the IPC. The revised definition extends beyond the initial August version, now encompassing acts threatening economic security and monetary stability.
Inclusions in "Terrorist Act"
- Intent to threaten economic security.
- Causing damage through production, smuggling, or circulation of counterfeit currency.
- Threatening unity, integrity, sovereignty, and security of the country.
- Causing harm through explosives, firearms, or hazardous substances.
Punishments for "Terrorist Act"
- Death penalty or imprisonment for life.
- Conspirators, abettors, or those facilitating such acts may face imprisonment of not less than five years, extendable to life sentence.
Acts Endangering Sovereignty and Unity: A Stricter Stance
BNS establishes penalties for acts endangering the unity and integrity of India, replacing the term "government" with "country." Section 152 retains aspects of sedition, punishing those attempting to incite secession, armed rebellion, or activities threatening sovereignty.
Sedition Under BNS (Section 152)
- Inciting secession or armed rebellion.
- Encouraging separatist activities.
- Endangering sovereignty, unity, and integrity of India.
Exceptions
Expressions disapproving government actions for lawful change are not offenses under this provision.
Mob Lynching: A Distinct Offense
BNS addresses the pressing issue of 'Mob Lynching' as a separate offense. Section 103 outlines severe penalties for groups committing murder based on various grounds such as race, caste, or community.
Penalties for Mob Lynching
- Death penalty or imprisonment for life.
- Fine for each member of the group.
As the BNS reshapes India's legal landscape, these amendments underscore a commitment to national security, societal harmony, and justice, reinforcing the legal framework to address evolving challenges.
BNS Reforms: Varied Penalties for Specific Offenses
Distinct Punishments for Medical Negligence
In a nuanced approach, the new Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) introduces a unique classification under Section 106 for doctors involved in cases of death by medical negligence. While the general punishment for such offenses is imprisonment up to 5 years, doctors, in similar circumstances, face a reduced penalty of imprisonment up to 2 years. This special provision sets a differential standard for the medical profession in cases of negligence leading to death.
Comparative Framework with IPC Section 304A
In contrast, Section 304A of the IPC, which deals with death by negligence, applies uniformly without a specific classification for doctors. The punishment remains imprisonment for up to 2 years, a fine, or both.
Stringent Measures for 'Hit and Run'
BNS takes a stern stance on 'hit and run' cases, prescribing severe penalties. Drivers causing death through rash and negligent driving, who fail to report the incident promptly to the authorities, may face imprisonment for up to ten years and fines.
Snatching Recognized as a Distinct Offense
Section 304 of the BNS introduces snatching as a separate offense, defining it as the sudden, forceful seizure or grabbing of movable property to commit theft. The penalty for snatching is imprisonment for a term up to three years, coupled with fines.
Decriminalization of Attempted Suicide
In a progressive move, BNS eliminates the criminalization of attempted suicide, a provision present under Section 309 of the IPC. However, Section 226 of BNS addresses attempts to compel or restrain lawful power, carrying penalties of simple imprisonment up to one year, fines, or community service.
Enhanced Fine for Negligence with Animals
Under Section 291, BNS significantly increases the fine for negligently omitting to take measures with animals in possession. This fine escalates from one thousand rupees under the IPC to a substantial five thousand rupees, reflecting a heightened emphasis on animal welfare.
As BNS refines the legal landscape, these amendments cater to specific circumstances with tailored punishments, showcasing a nuanced approach to justice.
Inclusive Definition: Transgender Recognized in BNS
In a progressive move towards inclusivity, Section 10 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) defines "gender" to encompass any person, irrespective of being male, female, or transgender. The use of the pronoun "he" and its derivatives is now inclusive of all gender identities.
Reference to Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019
The section further clarifies that the term "transgender" holds the definition ascribed to it in clause (k) of section 2 of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019. This alignment ensures consistency with existing legal frameworks, emphasizing the recognition and protection of transgender individuals within the broader definition of gender under BNS.
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita BNS | Indian Law | Kanoon | Law | New Indian Law | IPC Crpc |
